Behaviour factor assessment of ancient masonry towers through an innovative simplified pushover method

A. De Iasio, P. Wang, G. Milani, B. Ghiassi

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

The seismic vulnerability of masonry towers is a critical research field and it has an important role in the preservation of worldwide conservation of such kind of masonry building. Indeed, masonry towers have a very high seismic vulnerability and are often located in high seismic hazard zones. Researches about this topic have become even more frequent in the last decades. However, the results about the seismic behaviour of the masonry towers are still limited and further researches are needed. This paper aims to study the value of the behaviour factor (usually called q-factor or R-factor) of ancient masonry tower-like structures. This parameter provides quantitative information about the ductility of the tower and it can be computed by the capacity curve of the structure. In particular, the pushover curve can be bilinearized, and the q-factor can be computed according to the equal dis-placement or equal energy rule. The bilinearization of the capacity curve implies the knowledge of the ultimate displacement, whose computation is not a trivial task for this kind of structures because the capacity curves usually computed for such structures are apparently infinite ductility curves and the ultimate displacement cannot be directly computed. Therefore, an innovative pushover method (called “manual” pushover) has been formulated and implemented in a Matlab® code to achieve the q-factor computation goal. The tower is modelled by a vertical cantilever beam with lumped plasticity and it is loaded by self-weight and a user-defined horizontal distributed load profile. The non-linearities are modelled by the Moment-Curvature diagram of the cross-section where the plasticity is lumped. These cross-sections are positioned along the height of the tower splitting it into parts as uniform as possible in material and geometry characteristics. It allows considering the influence of openings and irregularities. The capacity curve is built by curvature control; it is similar to a displacement control and it allows to capture the softening branch and, consequently, to compute the ultimate dis-placement. This method is quick, computationally light and it has been properly benchmarked with FEM results. The obtained capacity curve fits the request of the q-factor computation method presented above. It is worth noting that the Moment-Curvature diagrams have been computed by a Matlab code based on digital image processing. In particular, it can read the geometry of a generic cross-section through its digital image representation and it automatically computes the diagram according to equilibrium, compatibility and energy considerations. Finally, the q-factor value has been computed for various real case-studies highlighting its strong variability on the tower geometry (e.g. slenderness and shear area). The results have been compared with the suggested behaviour factor given by the Italian Guidelines for Built Heritage (2011) and it has been found that the code suggestions overestimate the tower ductility and they are too limited.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationCOMPDYN 2021, 8th International Conference on Computational Methods in Structural Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering
EditorsM. Papadrakakis, M. Fragiadakis
PublisherInstitute of Structural Analysis and Antiseismic Research
Pages508-518
Number of pages11
Volume1
Edition1
ISBN (Print)9786188507258 (set), 9786188507234 (vol I)
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 30 Jun 2021
Event8th ECCOMAS Thematic Conference on Computational Methods in Structural Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering - Streamed from Athens, Greece
Duration: 27 Jun 202130 Jun 2021

Publication series

NameCOMPDYN Proceedings
PublisherEccomas Proceedia
ISSN (Electronic)2623-3347

Conference

Conference8th ECCOMAS Thematic Conference on Computational Methods in Structural Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering
Abbreviated titleCOMPDYN 2021
Period27/06/2130/06/21

Keywords

  • masonry towers
  • earthquake
  • simplified models
  • pushover
  • Matlab
  • behaviour factor

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Behaviour factor assessment of ancient masonry towers through an innovative simplified pushover method'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this