A revision of Vernicomacanthus Miles with comments on the characters of stem-group chondrichthyans

Richard P. Dearden; Jan L. den Blaauwen; Ivan J. Sansom; Carole J. Burrow; Robert G. Davidson; Michael J. Newman; Andy Ko; Martin D. Brazeau

doi:10.1002/spp2.1369

A revision of Vernicomacanthus Miles with comments on the characters of stem-group chondrichthyans

Richard P. Dearden^*, Jan L. den Blaauwen, Ivan J. Sansom, Carole J. Burrow, Robert G. Davidson, Michael J. Newman, Andy Ko, Martin D. Brazeau

^*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review

1 Citation (Scopus)

37 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The ‘acanthodian’ fishes provide key anatomical insights into the deepest branches of the chondrichthyan stem group. We review the anatomy of the acanthodian Vernicomacanthus uncinatus from the Lochkovian (Lower Devonian, 419.2–410.8 Ma) of Scotland based on eight articulated fossils, one of which is newly described. Broadly, the anatomy of V. uncinatus fits with that of contemporaneous acanthodians such as Climatius and Parexus, with a head covered by robust tesserae, an enlarged postorbital scale, an armoured shoulder girdle, and many pairs of ventrolateral spines. However, it departs from this anatomy in key respects. Its pectoral fin spines are obliquely ridged and posteriorly denticulated, similarly to Carboniferous gyracanth stem-group chondrichthyans. Its scales consist of multiple anteroposteriorly aligned odontodes, similarly to many Palaeozoic ‘sharks’. And its endoskeletal shoulder girdle may have a posterolateral angle, previously observed only in shark-like chondrichthyans. We propose that the differences between V. uncinatus and its congeneric, V. waynensis, which include potentially phylogenetically significant characters of the shoulder girdle and spines, are sufficient to erect a new genus for V. waynensis:Dobunnacanthus gen. nov. The scales of Vernicomacanthus are identical to those of the ‘shark’ scale genus Altholepis, suggesting that some such scales may instead belong to taxa with acanthodian-like gross anatomies. Based on these scales we highlight potential patterns in chondrichthyan scale evolution, in particular the axial addition of odontodes. Anatomical similarities between Vernicomacanthus and gyracanths, highlighted by previous authors, may indicate the existence of a grade including these and similar acanthodian-grade taxa placed relatively crownwards in the chondrichthyan stem-group.

Original language	English
Pages (from-to)	1949-1976
Number of pages	28
Journal	Papers in Palaeontology
Volume	7
Issue number	4
Early online date	29 Jun 2021
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.1002/spp2.1369
Publication status	Published - 13 Oct 2021

Bibliographical note

Funding Information:
We are very grateful to the museum curators who helped with access to material used in this study, particularly Stig Walsh at the National Museums of Scotland, Edinburgh, who kindly loaned a number of specimens and allowed us to prepare them, but also to Emma Bernard at the Natural History Museum, London, David Lampard, at the McManus Museum, Dundee, and John Johnstone, at Montrose Museum, Montrose. Many thanks also to Tom Davies at the University of Bristol, who helped with CT scanning, to Anna Jerve, for help acid‐preparing NMS G.2001.7.4, to Tomasz Goral at the Natural History Museum, London, for help with SEM, and to Plamen Andreev and Lisa Schnetz, for useful discussion. We are thankful to Mike Coates and an anonymous reviewer, whose comments improved the manuscript. This work was funded by a European Research Council grant awarded to MDB under the European Union's Seventh Framework Programme (FP/2007‐2013)/ERC Grant Agreement number 311092. RPD is supported by the Paris Île‐de‐France Region, DIM ‘Matériaux anciens et patrimoniaux’‐ DIM PHARE projet.

Funding Information:
We are very grateful to the museum curators who helped with access to material used in this study, particularly Stig Walsh at the National Museums of Scotland, Edinburgh, who kindly loaned a number of specimens and allowed us to prepare them, but also to Emma Bernard at the Natural History Museum, London, David Lampard, at the McManus Museum, Dundee, and John Johnstone, at Montrose Museum, Montrose. Many thanks also to Tom Davies at the University of Bristol, who helped with CT scanning, to Anna Jerve, for help acid-preparing NMS G.2001.7.4, to Tomasz Goral at the Natural History Museum, London, for help with SEM, and to Plamen Andreev and Lisa Schnetz, for useful discussion. We are thankful to Mike Coates and an anonymous reviewer, whose comments improved the manuscript. This work was funded by a European Research Council grant awarded to MDB under the European Union's Seventh Framework Programme (FP/2007-2013)/ERC Grant Agreement number 311092. RPD is supported by the Paris Île-de-France Region, DIM ‘Matériaux anciens et patrimoniaux’- DIM PHARE projet.

Publisher Copyright:
© 2021 The Authors. Papers in Palaeontology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of The Palaeontological Association.

Keywords

Acanthodian
Lower Devonian
scales
Scotland
shoulder girdle
stem-group chondrichthyan

ASJC Scopus subject areas

Palaeontology

Access to Document

10.1002/spp2.1369Licence: Creative Commons: Attribution (CC BY)

DeardenR2023RevisionFinal published version, 35.2 MBLicence: Creative Commons: Attribution (CC BY)

Cite this

@article{07866d4628194ceda5072580c3ea3740,

title = "A revision of Vernicomacanthus Miles with comments on the characters of stem-group chondrichthyans",

abstract = "The {\textquoteleft}acanthodian{\textquoteright} fishes provide key anatomical insights into the deepest branches of the chondrichthyan stem group. We review the anatomy of the acanthodian Vernicomacanthus uncinatus from the Lochkovian (Lower Devonian, 419.2–410.8 Ma) of Scotland based on eight articulated fossils, one of which is newly described. Broadly, the anatomy of V. uncinatus fits with that of contemporaneous acanthodians such as Climatius and Parexus, with a head covered by robust tesserae, an enlarged postorbital scale, an armoured shoulder girdle, and many pairs of ventrolateral spines. However, it departs from this anatomy in key respects. Its pectoral fin spines are obliquely ridged and posteriorly denticulated, similarly to Carboniferous gyracanth stem-group chondrichthyans. Its scales consist of multiple anteroposteriorly aligned odontodes, similarly to many Palaeozoic {\textquoteleft}sharks{\textquoteright}. And its endoskeletal shoulder girdle may have a posterolateral angle, previously observed only in shark-like chondrichthyans. We propose that the differences between V. uncinatus and its congeneric, V. waynensis, which include potentially phylogenetically significant characters of the shoulder girdle and spines, are sufficient to erect a new genus for V. waynensis:Dobunnacanthus gen. nov. The scales of Vernicomacanthus are identical to those of the {\textquoteleft}shark{\textquoteright} scale genus Altholepis, suggesting that some such scales may instead belong to taxa with acanthodian-like gross anatomies. Based on these scales we highlight potential patterns in chondrichthyan scale evolution, in particular the axial addition of odontodes. Anatomical similarities between Vernicomacanthus and gyracanths, highlighted by previous authors, may indicate the existence of a grade including these and similar acanthodian-grade taxa placed relatively crownwards in the chondrichthyan stem-group.",

keywords = "Acanthodian, Lower Devonian, scales, Scotland, shoulder girdle, stem-group chondrichthyan",

author = "Dearden, {Richard P.} and {den Blaauwen}, {Jan L.} and Sansom, {Ivan J.} and Burrow, {Carole J.} and Davidson, {Robert G.} and Newman, {Michael J.} and Andy Ko and Brazeau, {Martin D.}",

note = "Funding Information: We are very grateful to the museum curators who helped with access to material used in this study, particularly Stig Walsh at the National Museums of Scotland, Edinburgh, who kindly loaned a number of specimens and allowed us to prepare them, but also to Emma Bernard at the Natural History Museum, London, David Lampard, at the McManus Museum, Dundee, and John Johnstone, at Montrose Museum, Montrose. Many thanks also to Tom Davies at the University of Bristol, who helped with CT scanning, to Anna Jerve, for help acid‐preparing NMS G.2001.7.4, to Tomasz Goral at the Natural History Museum, London, for help with SEM, and to Plamen Andreev and Lisa Schnetz, for useful discussion. We are thankful to Mike Coates and an anonymous reviewer, whose comments improved the manuscript. This work was funded by a European Research Council grant awarded to MDB under the European Union's Seventh Framework Programme (FP/2007‐2013)/ERC Grant Agreement number 311092. RPD is supported by the Paris {\^I}le‐de‐France Region, DIM {\textquoteleft}Mat{\'e}riaux anciens et patrimoniaux{\textquoteright}‐ DIM PHARE projet. Funding Information: We are very grateful to the museum curators who helped with access to material used in this study, particularly Stig Walsh at the National Museums of Scotland, Edinburgh, who kindly loaned a number of specimens and allowed us to prepare them, but also to Emma Bernard at the Natural History Museum, London, David Lampard, at the McManus Museum, Dundee, and John Johnstone, at Montrose Museum, Montrose. Many thanks also to Tom Davies at the University of Bristol, who helped with CT scanning, to Anna Jerve, for help acid-preparing NMS G.2001.7.4, to Tomasz Goral at the Natural History Museum, London, for help with SEM, and to Plamen Andreev and Lisa Schnetz, for useful discussion. We are thankful to Mike Coates and an anonymous reviewer, whose comments improved the manuscript. This work was funded by a European Research Council grant awarded to MDB under the European Union's Seventh Framework Programme (FP/2007-2013)/ERC Grant Agreement number 311092. RPD is supported by the Paris {\^I}le-de-France Region, DIM {\textquoteleft}Mat{\'e}riaux anciens et patrimoniaux{\textquoteright}- DIM PHARE projet. Publisher Copyright: {\textcopyright} 2021 The Authors. Papers in Palaeontology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of The Palaeontological Association.",

year = "2021",

month = oct,

day = "13",

doi = "10.1002/spp2.1369",

language = "English",

volume = "7",

pages = "1949--1976",

journal = "Papers in Palaeontology",

issn = "2056-2802",

publisher = "John Wiley & Sons",

number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A revision of Vernicomacanthus Miles with comments on the characters of stem-group chondrichthyans

AU - Dearden, Richard P.

AU - den Blaauwen, Jan L.

AU - Sansom, Ivan J.

AU - Burrow, Carole J.

AU - Davidson, Robert G.

AU - Newman, Michael J.

AU - Ko, Andy

AU - Brazeau, Martin D.

N1 - Funding Information: We are very grateful to the museum curators who helped with access to material used in this study, particularly Stig Walsh at the National Museums of Scotland, Edinburgh, who kindly loaned a number of specimens and allowed us to prepare them, but also to Emma Bernard at the Natural History Museum, London, David Lampard, at the McManus Museum, Dundee, and John Johnstone, at Montrose Museum, Montrose. Many thanks also to Tom Davies at the University of Bristol, who helped with CT scanning, to Anna Jerve, for help acid‐preparing NMS G.2001.7.4, to Tomasz Goral at the Natural History Museum, London, for help with SEM, and to Plamen Andreev and Lisa Schnetz, for useful discussion. We are thankful to Mike Coates and an anonymous reviewer, whose comments improved the manuscript. This work was funded by a European Research Council grant awarded to MDB under the European Union's Seventh Framework Programme (FP/2007‐2013)/ERC Grant Agreement number 311092. RPD is supported by the Paris Île‐de‐France Region, DIM ‘Matériaux anciens et patrimoniaux’‐ DIM PHARE projet. Funding Information: We are very grateful to the museum curators who helped with access to material used in this study, particularly Stig Walsh at the National Museums of Scotland, Edinburgh, who kindly loaned a number of specimens and allowed us to prepare them, but also to Emma Bernard at the Natural History Museum, London, David Lampard, at the McManus Museum, Dundee, and John Johnstone, at Montrose Museum, Montrose. Many thanks also to Tom Davies at the University of Bristol, who helped with CT scanning, to Anna Jerve, for help acid-preparing NMS G.2001.7.4, to Tomasz Goral at the Natural History Museum, London, for help with SEM, and to Plamen Andreev and Lisa Schnetz, for useful discussion. We are thankful to Mike Coates and an anonymous reviewer, whose comments improved the manuscript. This work was funded by a European Research Council grant awarded to MDB under the European Union's Seventh Framework Programme (FP/2007-2013)/ERC Grant Agreement number 311092. RPD is supported by the Paris Île-de-France Region, DIM ‘Matériaux anciens et patrimoniaux’- DIM PHARE projet. Publisher Copyright: © 2021 The Authors. Papers in Palaeontology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of The Palaeontological Association.

PY - 2021/10/13

Y1 - 2021/10/13

N2 - The ‘acanthodian’ fishes provide key anatomical insights into the deepest branches of the chondrichthyan stem group. We review the anatomy of the acanthodian Vernicomacanthus uncinatus from the Lochkovian (Lower Devonian, 419.2–410.8 Ma) of Scotland based on eight articulated fossils, one of which is newly described. Broadly, the anatomy of V. uncinatus fits with that of contemporaneous acanthodians such as Climatius and Parexus, with a head covered by robust tesserae, an enlarged postorbital scale, an armoured shoulder girdle, and many pairs of ventrolateral spines. However, it departs from this anatomy in key respects. Its pectoral fin spines are obliquely ridged and posteriorly denticulated, similarly to Carboniferous gyracanth stem-group chondrichthyans. Its scales consist of multiple anteroposteriorly aligned odontodes, similarly to many Palaeozoic ‘sharks’. And its endoskeletal shoulder girdle may have a posterolateral angle, previously observed only in shark-like chondrichthyans. We propose that the differences between V. uncinatus and its congeneric, V. waynensis, which include potentially phylogenetically significant characters of the shoulder girdle and spines, are sufficient to erect a new genus for V. waynensis:Dobunnacanthus gen. nov. The scales of Vernicomacanthus are identical to those of the ‘shark’ scale genus Altholepis, suggesting that some such scales may instead belong to taxa with acanthodian-like gross anatomies. Based on these scales we highlight potential patterns in chondrichthyan scale evolution, in particular the axial addition of odontodes. Anatomical similarities between Vernicomacanthus and gyracanths, highlighted by previous authors, may indicate the existence of a grade including these and similar acanthodian-grade taxa placed relatively crownwards in the chondrichthyan stem-group.

AB - The ‘acanthodian’ fishes provide key anatomical insights into the deepest branches of the chondrichthyan stem group. We review the anatomy of the acanthodian Vernicomacanthus uncinatus from the Lochkovian (Lower Devonian, 419.2–410.8 Ma) of Scotland based on eight articulated fossils, one of which is newly described. Broadly, the anatomy of V. uncinatus fits with that of contemporaneous acanthodians such as Climatius and Parexus, with a head covered by robust tesserae, an enlarged postorbital scale, an armoured shoulder girdle, and many pairs of ventrolateral spines. However, it departs from this anatomy in key respects. Its pectoral fin spines are obliquely ridged and posteriorly denticulated, similarly to Carboniferous gyracanth stem-group chondrichthyans. Its scales consist of multiple anteroposteriorly aligned odontodes, similarly to many Palaeozoic ‘sharks’. And its endoskeletal shoulder girdle may have a posterolateral angle, previously observed only in shark-like chondrichthyans. We propose that the differences between V. uncinatus and its congeneric, V. waynensis, which include potentially phylogenetically significant characters of the shoulder girdle and spines, are sufficient to erect a new genus for V. waynensis:Dobunnacanthus gen. nov. The scales of Vernicomacanthus are identical to those of the ‘shark’ scale genus Altholepis, suggesting that some such scales may instead belong to taxa with acanthodian-like gross anatomies. Based on these scales we highlight potential patterns in chondrichthyan scale evolution, in particular the axial addition of odontodes. Anatomical similarities between Vernicomacanthus and gyracanths, highlighted by previous authors, may indicate the existence of a grade including these and similar acanthodian-grade taxa placed relatively crownwards in the chondrichthyan stem-group.

KW - Acanthodian

KW - Lower Devonian

KW - scales

KW - Scotland

KW - shoulder girdle

KW - stem-group chondrichthyan

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85108857908&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/spp2.1369

DO - 10.1002/spp2.1369

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85108857908

SN - 2056-2802

VL - 7

SP - 1949

EP - 1976

JO - Papers in Palaeontology

JF - Papers in Palaeontology

IS - 4

ER -

A revision of Vernicomacanthus Miles with comments on the characters of stem-group chondrichthyans

Abstract

Bibliographical note

Keywords

ASJC Scopus subject areas

Access to Document

Fingerprint

Cite this